Back to Search
ActiveSingle Family

$4,895,000

54 Fair St, Nantucket 02554

Beds5
Baths5.5
Sqft2,538
DOM9
No Photos Available

AddressIntel AI Briefing

No AI briefing available for this property yet. Processing may still be in progress.

Property Permit History

No permit history found directly associated with this property's address.

Recent Neighborhood Remodeling (Nantucket)

Parcel & Zoning Info

APN--
Official Lot Sqft--
Zoning Code--
SB 9 StatusBlocked

Hazard Snapshot

Flood Zone

None
No data available.

Fire Severity

None
Not in a mapped state fire severity zone.

Liquefaction

No data
Seismic data unavailable.

Fault Zone

No data
Seismic data unavailable.

Not a substitute for a Natural Hazard Disclosure (NHD) report. Zones reflect available GIS data and may not cover all localities.

Proprietary Intelligence

Market Heat Index

0/100

Based on recent sales velocity and local demand in 02554.

Flippability Score

0/100

Measures neighborhood renovation density vs. recent permits on this property.

Bidding War Prob.

0%

Likelihood of multiple offers based on local list-to-sale ratios and DOM.

Proforma ROI Calculator

Back-of-the-napkin deal analysis across development strategies.

Median of 12 recent single-family sales in Nantucket (02554): $1,349/sqft. Sized within 25% of the 3,800 sqft build, because smaller houses sell for more per foot and pricing a rebuild off them overstates resale.

Commission, transfer tax and closing. Deducted from resale before profit, so the ROI below is net of the exit rather than gross.

Carry on total capital for the project duration. At 0% the model is a cash purchase; 12 months at a typical construction-loan rate moves ROI by 6 to 10 points on a deal this size, so price it with your real rate.

Hard Costs$2,090,000
New Build3,800 sqft
Total Capital Required$7,160,000
Estimated Resale (ARV)$5,126,200
Cost of Sale (5%)-$256,310
Net Proceeds$4,869,890

Projected Profit

-$2,290,110
-32.0% ROI

Warning: Project is mathematically underwater.

Recent Comparables (Nantucket 02554)

Sized to the modelled 3,800 sqft build: sales within 25% of it. Smaller houses sell for more per foot, so pricing a rebuild off them overstates resale.

6 Mariners Way

Sold
$5,250,000
Sold: 2026-07-31
Lot: -
Sqft: 3024
$/Sqft: $1,736

23 Liberty St

Sold
$4,200,000
Sold: 2026-07-31
Lot: -
Sqft: 3262
$/Sqft: $1,288

2 Goldenrod Ct

Sold
$2,535,000
Sold: 2026-07-17
Lot: -
Sqft: 3029
$/Sqft: $837

6 The Captains Ln

Sold
$25,000
Sold: 2026-06-24
Lot: -
Sqft: 3400
$/Sqft: $7

25 Pine St

Sold
$4,800,000
Sold: 2026-03-30
Lot: -
Sqft: 3070
$/Sqft: $1,564

10 Milk St

Sold
$5,075,000
Sold: 2026-03-26
Lot: -
Sqft: 3597
$/Sqft: $1,411

10 Milk St

Sold
$5,075,000
Sold: 2026-03-26
Lot: -
Sqft: 3597
$/Sqft: $1,411

50 Lovers Ln

Sold
$4,340,000
Sold: 2026-02-27
Lot: -
Sqft: 3657
$/Sqft: $1,187

240 Polpis Rd

Sold
$8,565,000
Sold: 2025-12-16
Lot: -
Sqft: 4498
$/Sqft: $1,904

1 Chester St

Sold
$7,400,000
Sold: 2025-12-16
Lot: -
Sqft: 3467
$/Sqft: $2,134

10 Beach Grass Rd

Sold
$2,575,000
Sold: 2025-12-05
Lot: -
Sqft: 3985
$/Sqft: $646

8 Grey Lady Ln

Sold
$3,300,000
Sold: 2025-11-18
Lot: -
Sqft: 3251
$/Sqft: $1,015